Make plain sugar “cut-out” cookies in various Christmas shapes:

• Gingerbread-men
• Gingerbread-women
• Angels
• Star
• Hearts
• Musical note
• Gingerbread-baby
• House
• Candy cane
• Lamb
• Wise-men (I happened to have some wise men cookie cutters)

Invite each person to take one large cookie or a couple of small ones, to put them on their paper plate but not to eat them. 
Then ask them to find at least two scripture from the four chapters (Matthew 1 and 2, Luke 1 and 2) which would describe their cookie(s). 
They may choose what the cookies represent (i.e.: gingerbread-women could be Mary or Angels or Elizabeth; the gingerbread-men shepherds, Joseph, wise-men) 
They could then frost and decorate their cookies.

Adapted from Aleen Rockwood